
Calathes
Good, aggressive e-mail from Mike concerning a note in this morning’s column contending that Nick Calathes may be the best all-around player in the SEC:
Mike from Jackson writes:
Mr. Clay,
In what world of delusion is Nick Clathes the “best all around performer in the SEC”?
If you wanted to make the argument that he had the best all around performance in Tuesday night’s game, who could argue. But if you’re looking at the season as a whole, that’s a ridiculous contention.
Meeks is as good or a better shooter, as good or a better scorer, as good or a better free throw shooter. And Meeks does all this with MUCH more intense focus from opposing defenses. But if you go no further, the MOST you could claim is that it is a push.
But Meeks is so much better as a rebounder, and so VASTLY superior as a defender, that he leaves Calathes in the dust. Calathes is a very good player that any team would love to have. But I doubt you’d
find 10 coaches in D-1 that would take him ahead of Meeks on their team. INCLUDING Billy D.

Meeks
My reply:
Mike,
Thanks for the e-mail. I would debate you on one point — rebounding.
Going into the UK-Florida game, Calathes was 11th in the SEC in rebounding (conference games only) at seven per game. Meeks wasn’t in the top 30.
Meeks is the better scorer, even though Calathes did get 33 on Tuesday. And Meeks made the clutch shot at the end, while Calathes couldn’t knock down any of his three throws when Florida had a chance to send the game into overtime.
Calathes is the better passer. And you’re probably right, Meeks is the better defender.
Believe me, I love Jodie. I think he’s had a tremendous season, and he’s one of the better kids I’ve ever been around. I didn’t mean to knock Jodie. I’m just saying that I think Nick can do a few more things, even if his greatest strength is not as pronounced as Jodie’s greatest strength. (If that makes sense.)
It’s a fun debate to have, by the way.
By the way, the most recent nbadraft.net projections doesn’t list either Calathes or Meeks. It does have Patterson at No. 19.
Recent Comments